Society

Anonymous sperm and egg donation could end in Denmark

Anonymous sperm and egg donation in Denmark should no longer be available, according to the Danish Council on Ethics (Det Etiske Råd). In a recommendation published on 30 September, 14 of the 15 participating council members backed removing the anonymous option, while the government has invited parliamentary parties to discuss the issue as part of wider talks on fertility policy.

14 of 15 members want anonymous donation to end

Denmark is one of the few countries where people receiving fertility treatment can choose between an anonymous and a non-anonymous sperm or egg donor. The current system has allowed that choice since 2012.

With anonymous donation, the donor-conceived person never gains a right to learn the donor’s identity. With open donation, they can obtain that information at a later stage, most often once they are an adult.

The council majority argues that the interests of donor-conceived people should be given particular weight. Parents and donors can decide which form of donation they prefer, while the person conceived through the donation has no part in that decision.

Council chair Christine Nellemann told TV 2:

“Some donor-conceived people have a strong desire to know their genetic origins.”

The only member to take the opposite position was Stefan Hermann, who recommends retaining the choice between anonymous and open donation. He places greater weight on parents’ freedom to decide how to form their family and argues that secrecy about being donor-conceived can be a more important problem than anonymity itself.

DNA testing is making anonymity harder to guarantee

The council’s recommendation is also linked to technological change. Consumer DNA tests, online genetic databases and services that connect genetic relatives have made it increasingly difficult to ensure that a donor remains unidentified.

A donor does not necessarily need to submit a DNA test personally. Genetic information uploaded by relatives can sometimes be enough to trace family connections and identify them.

Nellemann told TV 2:

“With new DNA techniques and online genetic-profile registries, it is very difficult in practice to keep a donor’s identity secret.”

The council therefore argues that the distinction between anonymous and open donation is becoming harder to maintain in practice.

All council members also agree on two related recommendations. With an open donation, donors should be able to indicate in advance what kind of future contact or relationship they would or would not want. The council also says that any abolition of anonymity should not apply retroactively to people who donated under an explicit promise that their identity would remain protected.

Denmark’s sperm exports make the issue international

The debate has implications beyond Denmark. According to the council, Denmark and the USA are the world’s two largest exporters of donor sperm, and Danish sperm banks supply fertility treatment in several European countries.

The council says more than 80% of donor-conceived people in Norway are conceived using imported sperm, particularly from Denmark, while more than 60% of donor conceptions in the Netherlands use sperm from Danish donors.

There is currently no international limit on the number of pregnancies that can result from one sperm donor across national borders. The council says this means some anonymous Danish donors can be the genetic parent of up to several hundred donor-conceived people.

The fertility industry has raised different concerns about what ending anonymity could mean. Some representatives consulted by the council fear that recruiting donors could become more difficult and treatment more expensive, while others are less concerned.

Nellemann said Denmark currently recruits substantially more sperm donors than it needs domestically and that both parents and donors are increasingly choosing open donation.

The government is opening political talks

Health Minister Ida Auken, a Social Democrat, has invited the parties represented in the Danish Parliament (Folketinget) to discuss fertility policy, including anonymous donation. Her current ministerial role is confirmed by the Danish Parliament.

Auken said she understands why some donor-conceived people want access to information about their genetic origins.

“I have great understanding for donor-conceived people who want to know their genetic origins.”

She said families deserve decisions based on sufficient information and that anonymous donation will be among the ethical issues discussed with parliamentary parties.

The recommendation itself does not change Danish law. The Danish Council on Ethics is an advisory body, and any removal of the anonymous option would require a political decision.

The next question is therefore whether the government and parliamentary parties decide to turn the council’s recommendation into new rules, and how those rules would balance the interests of donor-conceived people, parents and donors.

Shares:

Related Posts