Politics

Meloni cites Stubb and Støre’s Putin call in EU unity warning

Meloni cites Stubb and Støre's Putin call in a letter calling for a single EU voice and a clear mandate in Ukraine peace talks.

Stubb and Støre’s Putin call has become part of a wider argument over Europe’s Ukraine diplomacy. In a letter sent on 5 November, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni cited the Finnish and Norwegian leaders’ contact with Vladimir Putin as one example of overlapping European initiatives that lack a clear common mandate.

Writing to European Council President António Costa, Meloni called for a decision on who should represent the European Union in negotiations over the war in Ukraine, and with what authority. She asked for the issue to be discussed at an informal leaders’ meeting in Dublin, with a decision at the December European Council.

Meloni questions who speaks for Europe

Meloni pointed to different diplomatic meetings in Miami, Oslo and Brussels, alongside the 27 October call from Helsinki by Finnish President Alexander Stubb and Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre. Her concern was that discussions in different formats could produce commitments without a collectively agreed EU mandate. She also called for consultation with Norway, the United Kingdom and other European partners before a decision.

The criticism did not establish that the Nordic leaders claimed to represent the EU. According to the Norwegian government’s account, Stubb and Støre spoke as national leaders, not on behalf of Europe. Their call followed talks in Oslo on 20 October and was conducted in consultation with Ukraine. Norway is not an EU member, although it is closely involved in European security discussions.

The Stubb and Støre Putin call had already caused disagreement

The question of coordination had already divided Nordic leaders. As NordiskPost previously reported, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen criticised the initiative, while Stubb and Støre maintained that their partners had been informed beforehand. The European Commission subsequently confirmed it had received advance notice.

Notification and a negotiating mandate are not the same thing. Meloni’s intervention moves the argument beyond whether the two leaders consulted allies to who can make commitments in Europe’s name.

EU leaders face a decision on representation

EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas agreed that Europe should not speak with competing voices. Asked about Meloni’s letter in Lisbon, she argued that Russia’s demands also concern decisions Europe must make, according to Aftenposten’s report. Her support for a common message did not amount to backing a particular negotiator.

At a 6 November briefing, the European Commission said it agreed with the need for a united position and with Costa’s response that EU interests should be represented by the Union’s institutions in line with its treaties. Costa had agreed to put the issue on the table in Dublin, Euronews reported.

No single EU negotiator has been appointed through the process Meloni is proposing. The question now is how national diplomatic contacts, including those by Finland and Norway, can be reconciled with a European position that has a clear mandate.

Shares:

Related Posts