Cross-border shopping in Denmark may cost the state far less in lost tax revenue than official estimates suggest, according to a new study from the University of Copenhagen. Researchers estimate that the state lost around DKK 415 million (€55.5 million) in 2019, compared with an official estimate of DKK 1.16 billion (€155 million), excluding tobacco.
The study, published in The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, used the closure of Denmark’s borders during the COVID-19 pandemic as a natural experiment. With cross-border shopping effectively unavailable during parts of 2020 and 2021, researchers were able to examine how much spending normally carried out in Germany returned to Danish shops.
Why the official estimate is higher
The difference comes largely from how lost tax revenue is calculated.
The Danish Ministry of Taxation‘s estimate assumes that money spent on products such as sweets, soft drinks and alcohol abroad would instead have been spent on equivalent products in Denmark if cross-border shopping were unavailable.
The researchers found that only part of that spending returns to Danish shops.
Magnus Munk Bjerg, a PhD student at the University of Copenhagen’s Department of Food and Resource Economics and one of the study’s authors, said:
“If we want to understand what Denmark actually loses, we need to look at what happens to consumption in Denmark.”
One possible explanation is that a trip to German border shops itself encourages people to buy more. Consumers who have driven a significant distance, sometimes with a car or trailer specifically for shopping, may stock up on quantities they would not otherwise buy during an ordinary visit to a Danish supermarket.
The researchers therefore stress that the difference does not mean the ministry made a simple calculation error. Instead, the two estimates are based on different assumptions about what consumers would do if the German option disappeared.
The effect is strongest close to Germany
The geographical differences are particularly large.
Households living within 30 kilometres of the Danish-German border increased their spending on these products in Danish shops by 109 percent when the border was closed.
The effect gradually declined with distance. For households living at least 120 kilometres from the border, the researchers found no statistically significant change in consumption when cross-border shopping became unavailable.
This suggests that cross-border shopping is much more important for households living near Germany than for Denmark as a whole.
The analysis is based on data from the YouGov Shopper panel, in which Danish households continuously record their grocery purchases. The researchers also tested their findings against a separate dataset from the Spenderlog app.
Cross-border shopping in Denmark and the debate over taxes
The findings could matter for Denmark’s debate over excise taxes on products associated with negative health effects.
Cross-border shopping has long been cited as an argument against higher taxes on products such as sweets, beer and other goods that can often be purchased more cheaply in Germany. The concern is that higher Danish prices may simply push consumers across the border, reducing both tax revenue and the intended effect on consumption.
The new research suggests that this effect is concentrated mainly among people who live relatively close to Germany. For most Danish households, the researchers argue, access to cross-border shopping does not substantially weaken the effect of these taxes.
The authors do not recommend a specific tax level. Instead, they argue that cross-border shopping should carry less weight than previously assumed when policymakers assess the consequences of changing taxes on these products.
The Danish Ministry of Taxation told DR that it had not yet had time to examine the study and therefore could not comment on its findings.





